Sports Debate: Ex-Giants QB Eli Manning 'at peace' with Hall of Fame miss

playahaitian

Rising Star
Certified Pussy Poster


Ex-Giants QB Eli Manning 'at peace' with Hall of Fame miss



Feb 7, 2025, 04:59 PM ET

Eli Manning isn't dwelling on his omission from the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame class.

The former New York Giants quarterback, speaking a day after the four-person class was announced, said he's happy for those who made it and isn't letting what happened sour his outlook on his career or the Hall of Fame overall.

"I'm excited for those guys that got in," Manning told NFL Network's "Good Morning Football." "All of them are so deserving. Happy for them. I texted a few of them, the guys that I knew, and just congratulated them.

"I had a feeling it wasn't going to be my night, and I understand that. And I'm totally at peace. It's not going to change my outlook of my career and how I feel about it."

The 2025 class includes tight end Antonio Gates, cornerback Eric Allen, defensive end Jared Allen and wide receiver Sterling Sharpe. It's the smallest class since 2005.

The group will be inducted Aug. 2 in Canton, Ohio.

Manning was in his first year of eligibility and had a complicated case for the Hall of Fame, leading to widespread debate on his candidacy. He led the Giants to two Super Bowl wins over the New England Patriots and two Super Bowl MVPs. He was top 10 all time in passing yards (57,023) and touchdowns (366) when he retired following the 2019 NFL season. And he never missed a game in his 16-year career because of injury.

But the biggest obstacle, according to some Hall of Fame voters in the room, was that Manning was never really in the discussion as the best player at his position for a chunk of his career.

Manning, of course, still can be selected as part of future classes. But a maximum of five modern-era players can be chosen each year, and first-time nominees for the 2026 class include Drew Brees, Larry Fitzgerald, Jason Witten, Frank Gore and Philip Rivers, so the competition will remain stiff.
 

tallblacknyc

Rising Star
Certified Pussy Poster
Happy sterling got in prob my fave reciever growing up… giant disrespect is something I’m used to..he’ll get in eventually just not today
 

JustChillin

Electric Relaxation
BGOL Investor
First off, let me say that I’m a Giants fan.

Now, I figured he’d get in off the strength of being a Manning, and winning in NYC. But he didn’t, and I’m not surprised.

The only year that Eli was in the top 5 convo was the year after the first ring. We were 11-1 and rolling and the Plex decided to shoot himself.

He is the all time passing leader for the Giants and #11 on the all time passing list.

And he carried the team on his back for the 2nd ring.

But if you’re not a biased Giants fan, I completely 100% understand saying he’s not 1st ballot.

He’ll get in eventually, just not now
 

HNIC

Commander
Staff member
Eli is not a hall of fame QB and he knows it.
He won those 2 Super Bowls and no one can take that away from him.
 

tallblacknyc

Rising Star
Certified Pussy Poster
Eli is not a hall of fame QB and he knows it.
He won those 2 Super Bowls and no one can take that away from him.
Troy aikman.. 161 td 141 int 32,942 yds( never threw more than 23 tds in a season)

Eli manning .. 366 td 244 int 57,023 yds(has 3 yrs of 30+ td)

if Troy aikman in the hall of fame than Eli definitely deserves to be in it.. he has 205 more td passes, 24,000+ more passing yds, and has double the amount of Super Bowl MVPs as aikman
 

djkidrich

τђë κïd fяºm qµęęñ§
Certified Pussy Poster
Troy aikman.. 161 td 141 int 32,942 yds( never threw more than 23 tds in a season)

Eli manning .. 366 td 244 int 57,023 yds(has 3 yrs of 30+ td)

if Troy aikman in the hall of fame than Eli definitely deserves to be in it.. he has 205 more td passes, 24,000+ more passing yds, and has double the amount of Super Bowl MVPs as aikman
morgan.gif
 
Top