Should All Student Debt Be Cancelled?

Should All Student Debt Be Cancelled?

  • Eliminate all student debt

  • Eliminate all student debt for households earning less than $100,000 a year

  • Eliminate some student debt for households earning less than $100,000 a year

  • Eliminate all student debt for households earning less than the poverty line ($25,750 a year)

  • Eliminate some student debt for households earning less than $25,750

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.

Rembrandt Brown

Slider
Registered
Sanders calls for wiping out $1.6 trillion in student debt by taxing Wall Street
By Andrew O'Reilly | Fox News
Published 2 hours ago

Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., proposed a plan Monday to eliminate all $1.6 trillion in student debt held by Americans by levying a tax on Wall Street banks.

Speaking outside of the Capitol building and flanked by Reps. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., and Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., Sanders called for the elimination of all student loan debt held by 54 million Americans – from both public and private educations – and making public universities, community colleges and trade schools free to attend.

“This proposal will make it possible for every person in America to get a college education no matter what their financial situation,” Sanders said. “We will make a full and complete education a fundamental right.”

He added: “It is unacceptable that the younger generation will have, under no fault of their own, a lower standard of living than their parents’ generation.”

Omar plans to introduce similar legislation in the House to eliminate student debt, while Jayapal – the co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus – has been a champion of tuition-free college.

Sanders said his plan, which would put a tax on speculation from major Wall Street banks, would raise more than $2 trillion over 10 years -- though some tax experts give lower revenue estimates. The proposal would hit financial institutions with a 0.5 percent tax on stock transactions and a 0.1 percent tax on bonds.

“In 2008, the American people bailed out Wall Street,” Sanders said. “Now, it is Wall Street's turn to help the middle class and working class of this country.”

Sanders' plan is the latest – and most aggressive – one from a 2020 Democratic presidential hopeful to tackle the mounting student loan debt problem in the country.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren, another 2020 hopeful, announced in April a plan to cancel existing student loan debt for millions of Americans. Under Warren’s plan, each person’s student debt would get relief of $50,000 if household income is up to $100,000. Higher incomes would also be entitled to big debt reductions, while households earning over $250,000 would get no student debt reduction.

Former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Julián Castro has introduced a more modest debt forgiveness plan as well.

Opponents of these proposals, including some Democrats, question why taxpayers should pay subsidies for the education of Americans who, on average, earn more than those with just a high school diploma.

Advocates, however, argue that student debt has become a major problem for the U.S. economy – reducing millennial spending power and putting home ownership out of reach for many, among other problems. The student debt burden has ballooned from $90 billion to $1.6 trillion in about two decades, according to federal data, and the average college student in the U.S. graduates with $29,800 in debt.

“There are currently 45 million Americans with student debt,” Omar said on Monday. “That’s 45 million people who are being held back from purchasing their first home; 45 million people who may feel that they can’t start a family; 45 million people who have dreams of opening a business or going into public service, but are held back.”






 

bgbtylvr

Rising Star
BGOL Investor
No. Reduce the interest on the loans. Allow refinance of current loans and extend amount of years to pay them back.

Edit: the loan should be considered forgivable if it’s worthless and students consistently cannot find jobs in that field or it no longer pays enough to pay back the loans.
 
Last edited:

Shaka54

FKA Shaka38
Platinum Member
Reparations first. Fuck your student debt. You idiots knew the deal going to college. I paid all my loans back, you pay your shit back too bitches
That is my opinion as well. Reparations first to ADOS before you go handing CACs yet another round of grants and handouts to the White population.
I voted in the poll to eliminate some for those households under 100K. It should go without saying that those under the poverty line should have it all forgiven.
 

Amajorfucup

Rising Star
Platinum Member
He had these positions when Warren was a kid running around pretending to be Native.
No. He had these talking points. The bastard had zero plans up until a fucking week ago. Warren rolled out positions and plans. Bernie, when asked about actual plans would kick the can down the road. Now, today, he has some vague "tax wallstreet" bullshit that will go absolutely no where. Eliminating all student debt is beyond unrealistic. Bernie sounds like a fool.
 

Rembrandt Brown

Slider
Registered
That is my opinion as well. Reparations first to ADOS before you go handing CACs yet another round of grants and handouts to the White population.

Why do you see student debt relief as a handout to whites?

I voted in the poll to eliminate some for those households under 100K. It should go without saying that those under the poverty line should have it all forgiven

Yes, that's how it is meant.
 

Rembrandt Brown

Slider
Registered
No. He had these talking points. The bastard had zero plans up until a fucking week ago. Warren rolled out positions and plans. Bernie, when asked about actual plans would kick the can down the road. Now, today, he has some vague "tax wallstreet" bullshit that will go absolutely no where. Eliminating all student debt is beyond unrealistic. Bernie sounds like a fool.
He has had over two dozen plans on his website for quite some time.
 

Dr. Truth

QUACK!
BGOL Investor
Crab in a barrel
Excuse me? This old faggit said we don’t have money for reporations but is for forgiving trillions in self inflicted school loans? Fuck him. I came from a poor ass shitty city and was able to pay shit back . I made wise choices why the fuck can’t the rest of these graduates.

I want my fucking reparations for all the pain we as a people have gone through and continue to go through. Fuck a college loan reparation
 

Fright Night

Rising Star
BGOL Investor
Excuse me? This old faggit said we don’t have money for reporations but is for forgiving trillions in self inflicted school loans? Fuck him. I came from a poor ass shitty city and was able to pay shit back . I made wise choices why the fuck can’t the rest of these graduates.

I want my fucking reparations for all the pain we as a people have gone through and continue to go through. Fuck a college loan reparation

Fuck a hand out!
What exactly do u want the white man to give all of us that no other race will receive??
 

Autobot8655

Rising Star
OG Investor
This dude is asking for a measly $10 trillion over 10 years for ADOS and you wonder why no one takes this bullshit movement seriously.

Where have you been?

There are hella people taking this shit seriously.

Were politicians discussing reparations in 2016, 2012, and so on?

In my adult life, this has been the most that reparations have ever been discussed.
 

Mr. Met

So Amazin
BGOL Investor
You think thats the problem? Asking for too much? You think the response would be different if he asked for $1 trillion instead?
Did you read what I said?

$10 trillion is not even pocket change.

10 years should at least hit the septillion mark.
 

jbug76

Star
BGOL Investor
This would be more universal than reparations. Give the entire economy a super fueled boost... majo5of black folks looking for 40 acres has student debt..
 

KingTaharqa

Greatest Of All Time
BGOL Investor
Where have you been?

There are hella people taking this shit seriously.

Were politicians discussing reparations in 2016, 2012, and so on?

In my adult life, this has been the most that reparations have ever been discussed.

He knows that. Mr. Met is anti-ADOS.
 

Dannyblueyes

Aka Illegal Danny
BGOL Investor
That is my opinion as well. Reparations first to ADOS before you go handing CACs yet another round of grants and handouts to the White population.
I voted in the poll to eliminate some for those households under 100K. It should go without saying that those under the poverty line should have it all forgiven.

Except that paying reparations first would end up with a lot of Black students getting liens put against their checks.

I voted that all student debt should be eliminated regardless of income or amount owed. Every dollar a student pays in debt is a dollar that's sucked out of the economy which makes it harder for others to pay off their debts. This in turn makes it harder for cities, counties and states to pay off theirs. Nixing student debts is the way to break this cycle.
 
Top