Dead man in Queens murder-suicide was entangled in bitter custody battle
By
Graham Rayman ,
Thomas Tracy ,
Rocco Parascandola ,
Rich Schapiro and Trevor Boyer
Jul 31, 2018 | 10:40 AM
Physical therapist James Shields, pictured here in an undated photo, has been identified as the dead man found in a Queens home with three other victims Monday night. (Obtained by Daily News)
An armed-to-the-teeth former city school teacher — enraged over a transatlantic custody battle — fatally shot his wife, ex-wife and 6-year-old son in Queens, police said Tuesday.
James Shields, 39, then killed himself inside his Astoria home where cops recovered two Glock handguns and 70 rounds of ammunition.
“That's an interesting wrinkle in this case,” NYPD Chief of Detectives Dermot Shea said, referring to the seven fully-loaded magazines. “What those rounds were meant for … may never be known.”
The bodies of Shields and his three victims — wife Saskia Shields, 38, ex-wife Linda Olthof, 47, and son James Jr. — were all discovered in the living room of his first-floor apartment on 30th Drive about 9 p.m. Monday.
James Shields was found with a gunshot wound to the chin, a black semi-automatic pistol lying nearby, police said.
Shields’ Netherlands-based ex-wife brought the estranged couple’s son to town on July 21 as part of an annual pilgrimage ordered by a Dutch judge, friends said.
Not long before Olthof and James Jr. arrived in the city, Shields posted a heated appeal for money on a GoFundMe page complaining that a nasty custody fight with his former wife had ruined his life.
“Due to my ex’s extreme jealousy and bitterness she is dragging me through court case after court case to be spiteful,” he wrote in the post titled “Child Kidnapping.”
James Shields was found dead with three other victims, including ex-wife Linda Olthof (left) and son James Shields, jr. (right), in an apparent murder-suicide in an Astoria Monday night. (Obtained by Daily News)
“In the Netherlands, the government pays for all legal expenses, so she’s enjoying this as it drags on and on ruining me,” he added.
Shields, a physical therapist and former teacher at Manhattan’s High School for Art and Design, claimed his ex only wanted their son in the U.S. for two weeks a year.
“This is devastating my family and I,” wrote Shields, who taught at the school for seven months in 2003. “The financial stress of this is destroying my current marriage and life. How do I choose between financially ruining my current relationship vs giving up the battle for my son?”
He added, “I had the perfect life a few years ago but it has spiraled out of control and I desperately need any help you can provide.”
The fundraising campaign, started three months ago, attracted no donors.
A friend of Olthof’s told the Daily News that she complained about having to drag her son across the Atlantic on her own dime to see an ex-husband who had a hot temper and refused to pay child support.
“She told me that some of the demands that he would make in court papers were totally one-sided and selfish,” said the friend, who asked to remain anonymous. “He put the financial burden on her.”
Armed ESU members are pictured at the crime scene Monday night in Astoria. (Go Nakamura / for New York Daily News)
The friend said Olthof, a former actress and dancer who was most recently working as a theater teacher, described her ex-husband as having an “anger-management problem.”
“She told me that he could flare up,” he added. “She was concerned about leaving the boy with him.”
Edward Indellicato, who lived on Shields’ block, said he learned to stop bringing up Olthof with his neighbor.
“I’d ask him, ‘How is Linda?’ He would shut me down right away,” recalled Indellicato, 91.
Shields’ father, James Shields Sr., confirmed his son’s custody battle Tuesday morning when he showed up at the crime scene.
Olthof was planning to take James Jr. back to the Netherlands next week, but James Shields Sr. said he had no reason to think his son would turn violent.
“He never talked to me much,” Shields Sr. said. “He kept everything a secret.”
“He’s a good man, a good boy,” the father added.
A friend of Shields posted a message on Instagram Tuesday saying he felt sick over not spending time with the man after their paths crossed two weeks ago.
“He wanted to hang out so bad, and now I see he was going through it,” the friend added. “I’m not trying to defend his actions in the slightest because they are disgusting and monstrous, but he was such a happy and positive guy.”
Why the kid though, man?” the friend added. “I can’t shake this guilty feeling like I could’ve helped him.”
Shields’ new wife Saskia, who was also from the Netherlands, used to work on the editorial staff for a magazine affiliated with the Dutch-Cypriot Chamber of Commerce.
Cops responded to the home after a porter who saw the carnage through a back window called 911.
"Financial and custody [seem] to be the primary reasons behind this tragic incident at this point in time," Shea said.
James Shields was found dead with three other victims, including ex-wife Linda Olthof (right) and son James Shields, jr. (left), in an apparent murder-suicide in an Astoria, Queens home on Monday, July 30, 2018. (Obtained by Daily News)
Neighbors said they often heard people screaming at each other inside the apartment.
“It would seem like it was a frequent thing,” neighbor Ellie Alvarado said. “Different times of day, there was some kind of yelling coming from the apartment.”
Tony Bekan, who also lived nearby, said his wife described Shields as a Dr. Jekyll Mr. Hyde kind of person.”
“He was kind of not himself all the time,” added Bekan.
James Shields, Sr., right, sits in front of the building where his son and others were killed in Queens. (AP)
Shea said police responded to the home last December for a domestic disturbance.
A woman greeted cops at the door but refused to provide her ID. She had told the 911 dispatcher that the man had already left.
The triple-murder suicide left family members reeling on two continents.
Cops said a male friend of Olthof who wanted to see the city had also traveled to New York so they could enjoy the sights together.
When the friend couldn’t reach Olthof on Monday night, he got in touch with her sister in the Netherlands, cops said.
“The sister then actually Googled New York, saw the tragic accident … she believed when she saw those stories that something had befallen her sister,” Shea said.
Olthof’s relatives are flying to the city to speak to detectives, he said.
In a 2008 interview with a Dutch newspaper, Olthof detailed her love of the Big Apple.
“In New York my ambition flares up,” she said. “You get the feeling, 'If you can do it here, you can do it anywhere.' That feeling dominates this city. '”
— With Ben Chapman, Elizabeth Elizalde, Irene Spezzamonte, Molly Crane-Newman, Mikey Light and Esther Shittu
http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york...ied-murder-suicide-queens-20180731-story.html