As President JOE BIDEN delivered his commencement address at Morehouse College, ticking through his biography, threats to democracy and the accomplishments he’d made for Black voters, the response from the audience was muted.
But that didn’t mean students weren’t reacting. A GroupMe chat involving the senior class of 2024 was humming throughout. And the reviews were rough.
Few said they were impressed by the president’s remarks, according to three students in the chat who described it to West Wing Playbook. Some expressed boredom. Others chimed in that they wished Rev. REGINALD WAYNE SHARPE JR., who delivered a moving and inspirational baccalaureate speech to the class the day before, had been given the commencement slot instead.
“[Biden’s] speech didn’t move me at all. It was very much so a campaign speech. Like, ‘Oh I did this for the Black community,’” said JEREMY MENSAH, a 2024 Morehouse graduate who voted for Biden in 2020 but was unsure how he would vote this November. “I didn’t feel connected to it.”
Not everyone in the crowd was sour on Biden. KERRY DEMOND SINGLETON, another ’24 grad, said he was “extremely impressed by his direct approach to the issues and concerns of the Morehouse graduates.”
But the larger, unenthused response underscored a painful reality for the White House as it aims to shore up its standing before the November election. The problem the president faces on college campuses isn’t just protests — it’s apathy.
Biden’s 30-minute long address at the historically Black college featured no major disruption or protest over the Israel-Hamas war, which many Democrats had feared. And for that, the White House was relieved. But Biden’s team doesn’t need to just sidestep public demonstrations, it needs to turn out new or on-the-fence voters. And there was little evidence on Sunday that Biden had been able to do that — at least on a large scale.
“He went on for a little bit, kind of a rant. I didn’t know what he was talking about for a while,” said ISAIAH WHITE, a 2024 graduate. “No one really clapped when Biden was talking. I think honestly it said a lot. Like, ‘You’re our president, cool. We’re here for Morehouse but we don’t really support what you’re doing.’”
Biden’s Morehouse speech was highly anticipated given that it was the first time he addressed a large group of college students since pro-Palestinian protests broke out at schools across the country earlier this spring. He used the opportunity to not just list the achievements his administration has made for Black Americans and historically Black colleges, like Morehouse, but to express empathy with the plight of the Gazans. He noted that he had a family member who was also distraught at the humanitarian crisis there.
Beyond the scattered applause — and a good laugh when he said his vice president, KAMALA HARRIS, would be the first HBCU grad to serve as president, before any of them — there was little reaction.
Part of it may have been the tension that had built up over the weeks before, with the college’s president threatening to shut down the ceremony if public protest ensued. But the students also read it another way: that Biden doesn’t have the formula or the capacity to excite them.
“That was a disappointment. Classic politician. It felt rehearsed,” said HASANI COMER, class of 2023.
Some Democratic operatives close to the White House viewed the speech as a natural opportunity for Biden to reengage with young Black voters, particularly at a time when polls show former President DONALD TRUMP cutting into Biden’s lead among this demographic.
Some Democrats, along with students, advised the White House to keep the speech focused on the students’ achievements and to not make it too much of a campaign pitch or get bogged down in responding to campus debates about the Israel-Hamas conflict. Others suggested that Biden talk about his economic vision and his plans to invest in the Black community.
And despite general apathy among students whom West Wing Playbook spoke with, a few walked away grateful to have seen the president. “The president had a difficult job,” said HERBERT JONES, a 2024 graduate. “I’m satisfied with it.”
But as they made their way across the damp lawn at the conclusion of the ceremony, several students expressed envy about the commencement ceremony taking place later that afternoon at the neighboring sister school, Spelman College. Actress ANGELA BASSETT was this year’s commencement speaker and Supreme Court Justice KETANJI BROWN JACKSON was presented with an honorary Doctor of Laws degree.
“Biden receiving the honorary award was in poor taste,” said DALTON FAVORS, class of 2024.
“It was the wrong choice to make. A Morehouse man is one that cares about peace internationally.”