Pavlik is pretty good, but to base his skills on those three fighters is kind of sketchy...I did not see the Zartuche fight, but looking at his bouts against Miranda and Taylor, I had little to no doubt that he would lose to either fighter...IMO niether one of them has clearly won a significant fight in their careers yet...
To this day, I scold myself for picking Lacy to beat Joe in his home turf...Jeff is still green when it comes to boxing skill...I should have saw that when I went to his fight against Robin Reid...Reid was overrated himself...
As far as I know, Joe's toughest fight was against Kessler and like you said, he's more of a linear fighter than most would see in other weight classes...Joe has been the only guy in the division who moves around the ring that has been in the title fights for that division. Bika, Bute, and Green haven't been in the forefront of the division, and Bute has the IBF title...Go figure...
And I still think that Calzaghe didn't do enough to beat the champ (B-Hop) to take his belt, but the prospect of Calzaghe-Jones was too big for the "money-makers" to pass up...I don't like Jones, but for once I would like to see him win this one.
For Floyd's comments, it would be interesting to watch his fights on HBO (ex. against Baldomir, Gatti, Bruseles, etc.) and check the commentary on that compared to Oscar's fights or Cotto (like his upcoming fight) or Arturo's and see what differeces occur. But in most cases it does not matter what color the fighter that's in the ring, it's who brings in the most money...